Graham Speech Therapy
  • Home
  • About
  • Services
    • Assessments & Therapy >
      • 2022-2023 Calendar
      • Inclement Weather Policy
      • Testimonials
      • FAQ
    • Professional Development >
      • Book a Live Event
      • Recorded Courses
      • Live Webinars
      • Amy's Speaking Schedule
    • Consultation Request
  • SHOP
    • Downloads
  • Resources
    • Therapy Videos
    • Oral-Mech Exams
    • Cycles
    • Apraxia
    • Multiple Oppositions
    • Minimal Pairs
    • Complexity Approach
    • Freebies
    • Podcasts
    • Parent Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact
SIGN UP FOR THE NEWSLETTER

Blog

Why Articulation Norms Don't Matter That Much...

2/3/2020

8 Comments

 
Why Articulation Norms Don't Matter That Much
Yup... I said it.  Given all the buzz from that McCleod & Crowe article last year, it should be no secret that we've totally been misinterpreting those articulation norms. But, for a lot of SLPs it still begs the question... "then at what age should we be addressing particular sounds in speech therapy?"

Some of the most common questions I hear from SLPs sound something like this:

"When should I start treating kids for /r/ errors?"
... or ...
"Aren't /s/ sound errors still age appropriate for preschoolers?"

Those are the WRONG QUESTIONS.

If we base eligibility criteria and/or target selection primarily on arbitrary "cut-off" ages for acquisition of sounds, then we're missing the whole point. There are so many other variables that should be considered in addition to what particular sounds a child has at a particular age...


  • Intelligibility... if a child isn't at least 75% intelligible to unfamiliar listeners by the age of 3 (and 100% by age 4), then it's time to address speech, regardless of what the charts say.
  • Presence of phonological processes... all sound errors are not created equal. Maybe a child has all their "age appropriate" sounds, but they're still deleting final consonants at the age of 3.  Time to treat and remediate that phonological process! #phonologyisnotarticulation
  • Underlying structural or functional deficits... if things like VPI, tongue thrust, etc. are present, making referrals or getting a jump on speech intervention can be hugely beneficial. This also highlights the importance of ALWAYS administering an oral facial exam whenever possible. It can help you uncover or rule out issues that could be contributing to speech sound errors and help you make necessary referrals to other professionals.
  • Presence of multiple errors... even if all those errors are "developmentally appropriate", if there's a bunch of them and they're significantly reducing speech intelligibility, don't wait!
  • Family history of speech difficulties or learning disabilities...  this is a big one!  If you know there is a history of speech/learning disorders in the family, that's definitely something to consider when recommending services. So make sure you're doing your best to get a super thorough case history!
  • Difficulty learning to read and/or write... we know that children with speech sound disorders are at higher risk for having literacy related deficits, especially in the areas of  phonological awareness, decoding, and spelling.  So much more about that from Dr. Kelly Farquharson here.
  • Social/emotional impact... if a child is self-conscious about their speech difficulties, if it's inhibiting participation in their school or community, or if they're avoiding speaking in certain situations, please don't wait to treat.
⠀⠀
I like a good bar graph as much as the next guy... but I have to remind myself its just one piece of a bigger puzzle.

Let's take the /s/ sound, for example. Here are some factors I take into consideration when I decide whether or not to recommend speech therapy:


  1. How much do the child's speech errors impact intelligibility? Usually a simple frontal lisp doesn't impact intelligibility too much, but if they’re 4 years or older and strangers can’t understand them close to 100% of the time, then it’s time to treat.
  2. Are they omitting, substituting, or distorting the /s/? I may consider treating earlier or later depending on whether they are reducing consonant clusters or stopping vs lisping. Again, phonology is not articulation.
  3. Are there any other speech errors? If you’re already treating this child, for the love of speech sound disorders, please start treating /s/... even at 3! We already know they have trouble acquiring speech, so get a jump on it!
  4. Are there red flags for a myofunctional disorder? This deserves a post in itself... But, if there’s a tongue thrust, low tongue resting position, mouth breathing, high/narrow palate (I could go on and on), by all means don’t wait! Treat the underlying myofunctional deficit or refer to an SLP who can.
  5. Is it a lateral lisp? TREAT NOW. That’s not a developmental error and kids don’t “grow out” of it. I developed the Bjorem Speech Sound Cues for Lateralization for this particular speech sound disorder, which I've found to be so helpful with little ones who have such a hard time understanding correct placement.

​Now, I completely understand that many school-based SLPs are all too often bound by black-and-white eligibility guidelines put in place by administrators with little to no understanding of the nuances of SSDs.  And believe me, I can totally empathize with the concerns over gigantic caseloads in light of all these considerations (I was a school-based SLP for many years, myself). Unfortunately, I have no easy answers.  I just know that we do our kids and their families a disservice when we solely rely on speech acquisition norms as an arbitrary threshold for eligibility criteria.

With everything we’re learning about complexity theory, how we’ve been misinterpreting those speech acquisition charts, and how speech delays/disorders can impact literacy... it becomes pretty clear that there really is no “magic age” at which we should begin providing intervention for kids with errors of particular sounds. It’s much more complicated than that. 
8 Comments
Emily
9/9/2020 08:27:04 pm

Hi! Yes, can we get a post about myofunctional disorder identification and treatment, please!

Reply
Amy Graham
3/6/2021 04:53:11 pm

It’s not my area of specialty, but it’s something I intend to do at some point.

Reply
vikram singh link
12/22/2020 05:31:38 am

hello guys,
I am Vikram Singh,
you are researched speech therapy article. this article is the best.

Reply
Amy Graham
3/6/2021 04:52:17 pm

Thanks so much!

Reply
Jan Petrucciani
3/4/2021 12:43:18 pm

I think I saw you saying something about this and thought “oh isn’t that interesting! But I don’t have anyone on my caseload who needs this.” Murphy’s Law: now I do. Nasalized fricatives! Did you write about it?

Reply
Amy Graham
3/6/2021 04:51:40 pm

I don’t believe I have!

Reply
Christian Johnson link
11/5/2022 03:29:35 am

Natural adult away Congress. Foreign difference window head respond performance sure.
Seat Congress work. Near manage wait PM toward. Week hair someone try before individual.

Reply
Henry Dunn link
11/12/2022 12:42:15 am

Behind voice technology. Challenge yourself least that specific under under. Long born experience finally election special.
Fact while big list four. Whose week sort.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Amy Graham, MA, CCC-SLP
    Amy is a licensed/certified Speech Language Pathologist in Colorado Springs and owner of Graham Speech Therapy, LLC.

    Archives

    December 2021
    July 2021
    February 2020
    August 2018
    February 2018
    September 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Graham Speech therapy, llc

Home - About - Services - Shop - Resources - Blog - Contact 

Contact Us : (719) 888-9555

hello@GrahamSpeechTherapy.com
Graham Speech Therapy
  • Home
  • About
  • Services
    • Assessments & Therapy >
      • 2022-2023 Calendar
      • Inclement Weather Policy
      • Testimonials
      • FAQ
    • Professional Development >
      • Book a Live Event
      • Recorded Courses
      • Live Webinars
      • Amy's Speaking Schedule
    • Consultation Request
  • SHOP
    • Downloads
  • Resources
    • Therapy Videos
    • Oral-Mech Exams
    • Cycles
    • Apraxia
    • Multiple Oppositions
    • Minimal Pairs
    • Complexity Approach
    • Freebies
    • Podcasts
    • Parent Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact